Feels like we've been here before
One too many times
Doing like we always do
We were in heaven
But heaven fell through
I guess love is a catch twenty-two

Swear that we've been here before
It's harder every time
Two people playing pretend
We rewrite the pages
Again and again
But even the best stories end

So I'll make it easy
Yea, I'll take the blame
I'll let you hate me
To help ease the pain
I'm stuck on this feeling
I just can't explain
I used to be sure
But I don't think I love you anymore

I wish that I could hold you close
To fix a broken heart
Cause we know the magic is gone
But you're gonna find it with someone I'm not
And they're gonna love you a lot

And in twenty years I'll think of you
And wonder where you are
I know that you'll think of me too
We'll replay the memories
That only we knew
I'll always be grateful for you

So I'll make it easy
Yea, I'll take the blame
I'll let you hate me
To help ease the pain
I'm stuck on this feeling
I just can't explain
I used to be sure
But I don't think I love you anymore

I used to be sure
But I don't think I love you