Tell me the truth
Are we still the same as we were in youth?
'Cause I look nothing like me but maybe
you're looking for a perfect harmony

And she said oh honey
Honey, it's pretend
But she was my first real girlfriend
I gave her roses in a big bouquet
And she threw my heart away
Oh honey
Honey, I'm outside
And if I take you for a ride
Just like I did when I was seventeen
Will you be my enemy?

But once she was mine
She drew birthday cards and made me valentines
When we grew up she moved to New York City
And I went to Philly falling hopelessly

And she said oh honey
Honey, it's pretend
But she was my first real girlfriend
I gave her roses in a big bouquet
And she threw my heart away
Oh honey
Honey, I'm outside
And if I take you for a ride
Just like I did when I was seventeen
Will you be my enemy?

But you were right
She's not gonna wait forever
For me to change my mind
And so our love didn't grow

But there's a part of me
Oh I still believe
That you and me, we shouldn't be apart
I took a chance
I took you to the dance
And I would've given you my heart

And she said oh honey
Honey, it's pretend
But she was my first real girlfriend
I gave her roses in a big bouquet
And she threw my heart away
Oh honey
Honey, I'm outside
And if I take you for a ride
Just like I did when I was seventeen
Will you be my enemy?