Baby, I've been takin' my time Been holdin' back the one thing I really knew was mine The innocence was building up inside (?) And I knew I could hide whatever I wanted to Baby, how did you know What else gave me the one thing I needed to let go When you showed me you can open up your heart When I fall into your arms Be gentle with me Chorus: It's my first time (First time in love) My first time in love (First time in love) It's my first time (First time in love) And I wanna make it last No one ever before Had been strong enough to teach me What real love is for But the joy that comes from touching heart to heart And I just can't wait to start All over again with you And I, I can't define the way I feel Or should I try For the first time in my life My love is like a shining sun And I know that you're the one Be gentle with me Chorus I'm loving you How could you, girl, feel for me The love I was afraid of Was the love that set me free Tell me am I dreaming Or are you dreaming to Let me wake up from this dream next to you Chorus 'til fade