Same day, same night
Always fueling our fights
Like a fire in an empty house
Gone off somewhere
All I know is you're not here
You think I'd have learned by now

You say she's just a friend, well okay
Why's she showing up midnight on my birthday?
Why's she crying in your arms looking a mess?
And you're looking at me like you gotta confess
Not the first time you held her
Mascara stains dripping down your t-shirt
Now I'm packing a bag, but I gotta ask

Out of everyone, everyone else
Why'd it have to be Hailey?
Why'd it have to be Hailey?
Out of everyone, everyone else
Out of everyone, everyone else
Why'd it have to be Hailey?
Why'd it have to be Hailey?
Out of everyone, everyone else
Out of everyone, everyone else

You say that I've got it all wrong
But I think I know