Shooting stars in the dark as we whispered all our wishes
Perfect days as I tasted forever in your kisses
But you broke forever when you walked away
How can I believe you're coming back to stay

When every little thing you say is pulling me in
Whatcha want from me, watcha want from me
So come on, baby, don't say maybe, just say when
I'll give you all of me, all that's left of me
But I can't take another never after

So should I trust your eyes
just because they're burning into mine
Will you be here or disappear
just like you did the last time
Tell me the bitter truth and ease my mind
Because I'd rather you be cruel than kind

But every little thing you say is pulling me in
Whatcha want from me, watcha want from me
So come on, baby, don't say maybe, just say when
I'll give you all of me, all that's left of me
But I can't take another never after

Tell me the bitter truth and ease my mind
Because I'd rather you be cruel than kind

But every little thing you say is pulling me in
Whatcha want from me, watcha want from me
So come on, baby, don't say maybe, just say when
I'll give you all of me, all that's left of me
But I can't take another never
So either say goodbye or say forever
'Cause I can't take another never after