Too good to be true
We were ruined from the star
Thought it was amazing
When a girl stole your heart

So wait a minute captain
You forsaken your friends
Why does it seem so hard to understand that
She may not be around in the end

What was I thinking when I let you in
Who did I think you were to begin with
So stop all this talking, just get you walking
I wish that we were friends
But then again

Man, oh man
You really hit me hard
Practically spilled my guts
Over while she stole your heart
And I hope you're happy
With that bride-to-be
She just might leave you for
For some other guy that
She randomly meets

What was I thinking when I let you in
Who did I think you were to begin with
So stop all this talking, just get you walking
I wish that we were friends
But then again

You're only fooling yourself

What was I thinking when I let you in
Who did I think you were to begin with
So stop all this talking, just get you walking
I wish that we were friends

What was I thinking when I let you in
Who did I think you were to begin with
So stop all this talking, just get you walking
I wish that we were friends
But then again

But then....but then again

I shoulda know
I shoulda know